Healthy Mascara Guide: Best Natural and Organic Mascaras for Beautiful Lashes

If you are searching for the best natural mascara to add to your makeup bag, you'll find there are plenty of options to choose from. Mascaras can be challenging, especially if you have sensitive eyes, as the chemicals in many products can cause irritation.

The makeup you use is important, and products with too many chemicals may seep into your skin over time. The good news is that many brands are dedicated to creating high-quality, organic mascara, offering safe and effective options for consumers. These products are designed to help you look your best while protecting your eyes and skin.

We’ve reviewed some of the top brands and curated a list of the best non-toxic mascara options for those who value healthy mascara choices. Check out our top picks below.

1. 100% Pure

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Gluten-Free Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan
Special Occasion | Anniversary, Birthday, Date Night

If you are looking for a great everyday mascara that will give you both length and volume, consider this mascara from 100% Pure. This organic mascara will help your lashes look longer and fuller while delivering a smooth finish that won’t clump or flake.

There is a lot to love about this all-natural mascara it not only doesn’t have any harsh chemicals in it, but it has a bunch of great vitamins and nutrients in it as well. This mascara comes with Chamomile and Vitamin E in it that will enrich and nourish your lashes while making them look beautiful.

We also love that this water-resistant (and sweat proof) mascara is made without any parabens or gluten so you don’t have to worry about allergies getting in the way of you getting that beautiful full lash look.

SHOP 100% PURE

2. Skin2Spirit

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Non-GMO , Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan, Gluten Free
Special Occasion | Girl’s Night Out, Graduation, Prom

If you are looking for a mascaras that is hypoallergenic and designed with sensitive eyes in mind, then consider this mascara from Essence. This mascara is made with minerals and is all-natural, so you don’t have to worry about this mascara hurting your eyes. While this Skin2Spirit mascara may be organic and natural, it still adds plenty of length and volume.

While we love that this mascara is cruelty-free and vegan, it is also hypoallergenic for those who have allergies to worry about. You can get all of this in a mascara that also doubles as a serum too. This mascara will help nourish your lashes and lengthen them over time—so you can enjoy beautiful lashes both when you wear this product and when you don’t!

SHOP Essence

3. Pacifica

Type of Natural Mascara | Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan,
Special Occasion | Anniversary, Valentine’s Day, Mother’s Day

If you are looking for a quality mascara that will bring some length and strength to your eyelashes—then this mascara from Pacifica. This mascara will not only lengthen your lashes and help you look your best—but this mascara does all this in an organic package.

This mascara is perfect for everyday use and is designed to help separate the lashes while building volume. We love that this mascara is made without any harmful toxins, chemicals, GMOs or parabens. However, what we love even more is all of the things this mascara does include. This mascara has coconut oil and Vitamin B to help hydrate and strengthen you skin.

SHOP PACIFICA

4. Simply Naked Beauty

Type of Natural Mascara | Fiber Lash Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Not Tested on Animals, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan, Gluten Free
Special Occasion | Wedding, Bachelorette, Girl’s Night

If you are in need of some hypoallergenic makeup for your everyday routine, consider this mascara from Simply Naked Beauty. This mascara is a great alternative to false lashes if you want that full glam look but don’t want to deal with any of the harsh chemicals found in the glue. This mascara actually lengthens your eyelashes so much it gives off the look of false lashes.

However, the best part about this mascara is that it has some of the leading makeup technology out there right now—without all of the harmful additives that other makeup brands have. This mascara is made with USDA certified castor oil and is made only with natural ingredients. This company does not test on animals and has a hypoallergenic product that won’t irritate your allergies.

SHOP SIMPLY NAKED BEAUTY

5. Physician's Formula

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan
Special Occasion | Concert, School Event, Graduation Party

Physician’s Formula is known for creating quality, organic makeup products. This includes this organic mascara. This is one of the company’s most popular products because it not only helps open up your eyes and make you look more awake—but it is made out of safe and organic ingredients as well. This budget-friendly mascara will give you the look of false lashes, without all of the hassle.

This company is really dedicated to creating an organic, eco-friendly product. The mascara even has a recyclable eco-friendly brush that helps you get an even application with your mascara. Our favorite feature of this product, however, is that 70% of the total ingredients from this mascara are actually made from organic farming. The result is a mascara that is hypoallergenic and free from harsh chemicals, parabens or toxins that you don’t want near your face.

SHOP PHYSICIAN’S FORMULA

6. Burt's Bees

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan, Gluten Free
Special Occasion | Birthday, Anniversary, Night Out

While many people know Burt’s Bees for their natural and organic lip balms, this brand also makes a number of other safe and natural makeup products. This classic mascara is made out of all-natural ingredients including Jojoba Oil which will actually help moisturize your lashes and keep them healthy.

We love that this lengthening mascara delivers outstanding results, but is made with Glycerin—which is safe enough for use around the eyes.

This mascara will strengthen and condition the lashes, while still helping you look your best. We love that this all-natural mascara is not only effective, but it is also ophthalmologist-tested. This means that it is safe for individuals who have sensitive eyes or eye allergies.

SHOP BURT’S BEES

7. Ecco Bella

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan
Special Occasion | Bacherlotte Party, Bridal Shower, Wedding

This mascara from Ecco Bella is a great addition to any natural makeup bag. This mascara is great for anyone with sensitive eyes and while it is gentle and hypoallergenic, it is also designed to help make our lashes look their best.

This mascara will add both length and volume to your natural lashes.

SHOP ECCO BELLA

8. Naturally Rooted

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan, Made in USA
Special Occasion | School, Getting Coffee With Friends, Dinner Date

Looking for a safe and natural mascara? This option from Ilia is the perfect piece of makeup for you. This all natural mascara comes in standard black and will give your lashes a natural boost of length and volume—so your lashes can look fuller but will still feel natural.

This mascara is great for causal events and everyday looks as it comes in a soft black/brown that looks very natural. We love that this product is made in the USA and designed for sensitive eyes. Other features that make this mascara one of our favorites include that it is vegan, gluten-free and made without any parabens.

SHOP Ilia

9. KC Republic

Type of Natural Mascara | Natural Organic Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Gluten-Free, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Hypoallergenic
Special Occasion | Easter, Christmas, Holiday Parties

If you are looking for a new mascara for your makeup collection, consider this option from Honest Beauty. This mascara was made specifically for those who have allergies and eye sensitivities.

This hypoallergenic mascara is not only safe and organic, but it really works and adds length and volume to the lashes. We also love that this organic mascara actually nourishes your natural lashes.

This mascara is a great addition to your everyday routine, because it not only gives you an instant look of fuller and longer lashes, but it will actually help you get naturally fuller and longer lashes as well. This mascara will strengthen and condition your lashes thanks to ingredients such as Vitamin E, Chamomile and Jojoba Oil.

Plus, this non-toxic mascara comes in an eco-friendly tube! This is really a piece of makeup that you will feel good about buying.

SHOP Honest Beauty

10. Honest Beauty

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Primer and Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan, Gluten Free
Special Occasion | Anniversary, Birthday, Date, Girl’s Night

If you are looking for a mascara that will add some serious length to your lashes, consider this Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara. This mascara is made with all-natural ingredients and will give you that full glam look without bothering your eyes. We love that this makeup isn’t just mascara—it is both a mascara and a primer that adds extra definition, volume and length. With the primer, this mascara can give more of a false lash look.

This mascara features a primer that boosts volume and length. We love that this mascara is not only able to create a stunning lash look, but it is also dermatologist-tested so you don’t have to worry about this mascara irritating your eyes. This lengthening and volumizing mascara truly is a win-win.

SHOP HONEST BEAUTY

11. Cherisher

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan,
Special Occasion | Christmas, New Year’s Eve, Hanukah Dinner

If you want that glamorous full volume look on your lashes, then consider this mascara from Cherisher. This mascara will both lengthen your lashes and add volume. We love that this mascara is enriched with vitamins that will help nourish and grow your natural lashes—all while helping your lashes look longer and fuller.

This mascara is also hypoallergenic, making it great for those who have allergies and eye sensitives as it has been tested to be free from harmful chemicals and is great for those who wear contacts or have very dry, irritated eyes. This is all thanks to the natural formula of this mascara that uses plenty of vitamins to nourish the lashes while helping them grow longer.

SHOP CHERISHER

12. Dr. Brenner

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens
Special Occasion | Birthday Party, Night Out, Date Night

This all-natural mascara from Dr. Hauschka is not only a great addition to your makeup bag, it is also a great way to nourish your lashes as well. This mascara can actually help your natural lashes stay healthy application after application. The other thing that we love about this natural mascara is that it is designed to prevent clumping, so you can add multiple layers and your lashes will still look smooth.

This mascara also prevents against smudging, so you can rest assured that your mascara will stay in place all day long. We love the smart features of this simple, budget-friendly mascara which is sure to make a great addition to any makeup bag.

SHOP DR. Hauschka

13. Petra Organics

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Waterproof Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens
Special Occasion | Birthday Dinner, Anniversary Celebration, Work Happy Hour

If you are looking for a quality mascara, then consider mascara from Bare Minerals. This mascara is filled with vitamins and is great for your natural lashes—all while giving you a full makeup look. This waterproof mascara will stay put all day and thanks to the 4D fiber technology—it will give you the look of false lashes, but in a tube. It is made without any harmful toxins and instead uses green tea and natural silk powder.

We love all of the features of this organic mascara, and that it is enriched with vitamin E to stimulate the growth of your lashes while conditioning them. This will help you get fuller, longer, more natural-looking lashes that you will love, even when you aren’t wearing this mascara.

SHOP Bare Minerals

14. 100% PURE

Type of Natural Mascara | Organic Black Mascara
Natural Mascara Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Non-Toxic, Cruelty-Free, No Parabens, Vegan
Special Occasion | Gala, Wedding Reception, Cocktail Party
Price of Natural Mascara | $28

This all-natural mascara from 100% Pure really lives up to its name… it is completely pure and natural. But that isn’t all this mascara offers. This mascara will lengthen your lashes and strengthen them at the same time. In fact, the natural ingredients and extracts in this mascara will make your lashes stronger and healthier as you use it.

This is thanks to natural vitamin B5, wheat protein and oat protein they use in their formula. Another great feature of this all-natural mascara? It is actually smudge proof so it will look just as good when you leave work at the end of the day as it did when you put it on in the morning.

We love that this lash extension mascara will give you a false lash look, without the harmful toxins that come with lash glue. Instead, this brand uses safe and natural ingredients and never tests those ingredients on animals.

SHOP 100% PURE

Organic Mascara Must-Haves: Best Non-Toxic and Healthy Choices for Your Makeup Bag

The right makeup and mascara can transform your look and enhance your natural beauty. To avoid irritation or exposure to harmful toxins, it’s crucial to choose a non-toxic mascara that is both safe and effective.

Opting for a natural or organic mascara ensures you can achieve your desired look without compromising your health. Explore our curated list above for the best natural mascara options to suit your needs.

Lisa Czachowski is a professional social blogger and has worked on several online publications including Citrus Sleep. Lisa is an experienced content writer and copyeditor. You will find many of her works throughout CitrusSleep.com that cover a wide array of subjects including sustainability, natural, sleep products, health, fashion and many more. She is passionate about what providing as much information as possible on products you bring in your home and what we wear.

Follow Lisa at Lisa Czachowski