Why Every Pet Owner Needs the Best Dog Toys: Indestructible, Squeaky, and Safe Options for All Dogs
Every pet owner wants the best dog toys for their beloved canine companion. For many dogs, toys provide hours of joy, but not all toys are safe.
Chewing and playing can sometimes lead dogs to swallow parts of their toys, making it essential to choose safe, natural options. Whether you're looking for an indestructible dog toy, a fun dog squeaky toy, or durable dog chew toys, ensuring your pet’s safety should always come first.
With so many options available, we’ve reviewed the best natural and safe dog toys, including options for small dog toys and large dog toys. This way, you can buy with confidence, knowing your pup is playing safely with their new favorite toy.
Here’s our list of top-rated toys your canine will love.
1. Riverbend Home
Type Natural Dog Toy | Plush Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Yellowstone National Park, Yosemite National Park
Natural Dog Toy Price | $51
Most pet owners know that plush dog toys can sometimes be a risk—especially for pups that are heavy chewers. Fortunately for dog owners, they can rest easy with this plush unicorn dog toy from Riverbend Home. For our Riverbend Home review, this dog toy isn’t just cute and fun to play with, it is also made with safe and natural materials as well. This is something that is very rare in a plush toy, and can help pet owners rest easy knowing that this product isn’t toxic.
We love that this toy is not only made out of safe and natural materials, but that it comes from a company that is truly dedicated to helping dogs and owners. This national brand is committed only to carrying quality products that pets can safely enjoy at home.
SHOP RIVERBEND HOME
2. Outward Hound
Type Natural Dog Toy | Plush Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Sustainable
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Glacier National Park, Wind Aves National Park
This fun giraffe toy from Outward Hound isn’t just adorable to look at, it is a fun toy for your pet if they love plush toys. However, there is even more to love about this plush toy. For our Outward Hound review, this stuffed dog toy is made out of safe, natural and organic materials. You can rest easy knowing your dog’s favorite new toy was made using sustainable materials and eco-friendly practices. The interior stuffing of this toy is even made out of a natural coconut husk stuffing instead of standard synthetic fill.
This giraffe is made with natural wool on the exterior, which is not only safe and non-toxic, but super durable as well. In addition to being a sustainable toy (which is great for everything from fetch to tug-of-war), this giraffe is soft enough for cuddling as well.
SHOP OUTWARD HOUND
3. One Kings Lane
Type Natural Dog Toy | Plush Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Sequoia National Park, Virgin Islands National Park
Natural Dog Toy Price | $15
Next on our list is our One Kings Lane review. This dog toy is sure to be your pet’s new favorite item to chew on and play with. However, this Sketch Bone dog toy from One Kings Lane isn’t just something your dog will love—it is a toy that pet owners will love as well as it is made out of safe and natural materials as well, so you can give this toy to your dog with confidence and not worry about them playing with something that will harm them.
This bone-shaped toy from Harry Barker is made out of organic cotton canvas that you can easily machine wash if it gets too dirty, making it easy for you to keep this product safe and healthy. The interior of this toy is even stuffed with an eco-friendly fiberfill, so you don’t’ have to worry about your pet accidentally chewing on any synthetic stuffing.
SHOP ONE KINGS LANE
4. ORVIS
Type Natural Dog Toy | Squeak Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | Duck 5” or Squirrel Sized 12”
Favorite National Park | Redwood National Park, Rocky Mountain National Park
Natural Dog Toy Price | $13-$15
While many people know of ORVIS for their quality, eco-friendly clothing for people—this brand also has a number of safe and natural products for dogs as well. This includes products such as this Animal Squeaker Toy. For our ORVIS review, this plush, animal-shaped toy has an included squeaker that will get your pet excited and ready to play—whether they want to play fetch or just chew all afternoon.
We love that this squeaky pet toy is not only soft enough for cuddling and durable enough for chewing—but that it is made of non-toxic materials. These toys are even hypo-allergenic and are great for dogs who have sensitivities or allergies. If you want to make sure that your dog is only playing with safe and natural products—then this toy is for your pet.
SHOP ORVIS
5. Eco Kit
Type Natural Dog Toy | Toy Kit
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | Customizable Size
Favorite National Park | Glacier National Park, Bryce Canyon National Park
If you are looking for a fun, but safe, toy for your pet—then consider this eco-friendly dog toy from Trixie. The best part of this kit is that you can actually make your own dog toy with your family for a fun craft that you can feel good about doing. For our Trixie review, this natural dog toy is made out of handcrafted, safe and non-toxic materials, so you don’t have to think-twice about what your pet is chewing on or playing with.
This toy is made out of handcrafted bamboo, organic cotton rope and natural plant fibers. This company is committed to making products out of non-toxic, natural and eco-friendly materials. We love that this company has a social commitment not only to creating safer and more natural dog toys, but reducing the amount of plastic that ends up in our landfills by recycling them and using them in their products. It is a great way to help your pet have fun while doing your best to help the planet.
SHOP Trixie
6. JEZBO
Type Natural Dog Toy | Chew Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | Multiple Sizes
Favorite National Park | Mount Rainier National Park, Kings Canyon National Park
If your pet loves chew toys, then this all-natural chew toy from Fringe is just what you have been looking for. For our Fringe review, this all-natural dog toy was designed with heavy-chewers in mind and your dog will love nibbling on this toy all afternoon long, while you will love that it is made entirely with safe and natural ingredients. There are three different toys in this teething friendly set: a ball, braided rope and hemp knot toy.
This set come with a few different toys that are great for chewing and teething. However, the best feature of this puppy play toy set is that it is completely eco-friendly and safe. These toys are made out of 100% hemp. This self-sustainable material is not only non-toxic, but it is a recyclable material that won’t end up in a landfill when your pup is done using it.
SHOP Fringe
7. JW Pet
Type Natural Dog Toy | Ball Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Made in the USA, Organic, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | Small, Medium, Large
Favorite National Park | Great Sand Dunes National Park, Smoky Mountains National Park
This fun toy from JW Pet is sure to keep your canine companion entertained all day long. For our JW Pet review, this Megalast Ball is a tough toy for active chewers. We love that this tough ball is made out of safe, recycled rubber. This toy is easy to chew on, will float in the pool and has compartments in it that you can fill with treats or peanut butter. The toy is even infused with natural vanilla extract to prevent the toy from getting too smelly.
We love that this dog toy comes in different sizes, so dogs of all types can enjoy this toy. We also love that it is made in the USA and 100% recyclable, so you don’t have to worry about this dog toy ending up in landfill some day.
SHOP JW PET
8. MHK Goods
Type Natural Dog Toy | Rubber Teething Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Glacier Bay National Park, Grand Canyon National Park
Next on our list is our Comtim review. If you have a teething puppy on your hands—then this Toothbrush Teething Toy from Comtim is a great option for your dog. This chew toy will help your pet while they deal with uncomfortable teething issues and will help keep your pet’s teeth clean and healthy. This is toy is not only a great way to easily keep your pet’s teeth clean, but it is also made out of durable, but natural rubber, that is super durable, while still very safe for your pet.
This 100% natural rubber dog tooth brush toy is made out of 100% natural rubber and comes with a fresh mint scent that will not only help keep your pet’s teeth clean, but help your canine companion enjoy better breath. This durable, quality dog toy.
SHOP Comtim
9. HETOO
Type Natural Dog Toy | Rubber Teething Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Bay National Park, Grand Canyon National Park
Do you have a teething puppy on your hands? This HETOO Toothbrush Toy is a great way to make sure that those new teeth are clean and healthy. Plus, it is a piece that they will love chewing on and one that will keep your puppy occupied for hours on end. For our HETOO review, we love that this toy is not only fun for pups, but that it features ribs and designs that will help get into the crevices of your pup’s teeth. Additionally, this rubber material is completely natural and safe so you don’t have to worry about any chemicals harming your puppy.
Chew toys are important for puppies and can help them keep proper oral and dental healthy. We love that this toy is made out of completely natural and non-toxic rubber. This eco-friendly dog chew toy even comes infused with fresh peppermint to help your puppy’s breath stay fresh while they chew!
SHOP HETOO
10. Paw Toys
Type Natural Dog Toy | Leather Chew Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Fair Trade, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | Bacon Size, Eggs Size
Favorite National Park | Denali National Park, Death Valley National Park
This squeaker toy is a great option for any pet who likes to stay active and engaged with his toys. We love this Paw Toys review for its cute design and durability. However, our favorite feature is that it is made out of safe and natural eco-friendly leather. We know this is a feature that pet owners will love as well.
This Paw Toys Squeaker Toy is made entirely out of eco-friendly and sustainable materials, including natural leather, coconut fibers and Jute rope. We love that this toy is not only natural but designed to withstand consistent chewing. Paw Toys knowns that it is important for dog owners to have toys that their dogs can chew on but that won’t harm them, which is why they created their entire line of sustainable, natural products.
SHOP Spot
11. Petmate
Type Natural Dog Toy | Water Bottle Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | Medium
Favorite National Park | Canyonlands National Park, Capitol Reef National Park
Natural Dog Toy Price | $13
If you are looking for a great toy for your pet who likes to chew and chew all day long—then consider this crunchy toy from Petmate. For our Petmate review, this toy has an opening to put a water bottle on the inside that makes a delightful crunchy noise and texture to it that your pet will love. Plus, pet owners will love that this toy is made entirely out of safe and natural materials.
We love that this toy is not only made with an eco-friendly and natural exterior of durable, organic canvas—but that it encourages dog owners to recycle their water bottles. Just put your empty plastic water bottle inside the toy and your dog can safely chew on and play with this cat-shaped toy with its fun crunching side effects.
SHOP PETMATE
12. Tall Tails
Type Natural Dog Toy | Leather Wool Dog Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Badlands National Park, Big Bend National Park
Natural Dog Toy Price | $15
There are many dogs who prefer to sit and chew on something durable all afternoon long, rather than engaging in play with a squeaky toy. If this sounds like your pup—then this Tall Tails natural wool antler toy is the perfect toy for your pet. For our Tall Tails review, this antler is safe, durable and tough-enough for even the heaviest of chewers to handle.
IT is made out of all-natural leather wool and is stitched with organic cotton jute rope. Whether you dog wants to play fetch, tug with their owner or just relax and snuggle with a toy—this wool antler toy is great for dogs of all types. We love that this toy can be used in a variety of situations, but that it is also made without any toxins, chemicals or artificial colorings—making it a truly natural addition to your pet’s collection.
SHOP TALL TAILS
13. West Paw Designs
Type Natural Dog Toy | Plush Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Made in USA, Recyclable, Give Back, Socially Responsible
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Acadia National Park, American Samoa National Park
Next on our list is our West Paw Designs review. This squeaky toy isn’t just cute—it is a fun for dogs as well. We love that this toy has a built-in squeaker that will get any dog excited and ready to play. However our favorite thing about this West Paw Designs Squeaky Storm Toy is that it is made with safe and natural materials.
We love that this dog toy is made out of eco-friendly materials so your pet can chew on this toy all afternoon long and you don’t have to worry about them chewing on any toxic materials. We also love that this dog toy was handcrafted using these organic materials right in Montana, meaning you can feel good about supporting a toy that was made right in the USA.
SHOP WEST PAW DESIGNS
14. AIZARA
Type Natural Dog Toy | Nylon Chew Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, Recyclable, FDA Approved, BPA-Free
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Yellowstone National Park, Zion National Park
Do you have a tough chewer on your hands? Then this AIZARA Indestructible Training Toy is for your pet. For our AIZARA review, this toy isn’t just super-durable and designed with heavy chewers in mind, but it is a safe and natural toy as well—so you never have to worry about your dog chewing away on this toy all day long. This toy can help chewing puppies reduce plaque and tartar for better chewing habits.
However, what is most unique about this product is that it is made out of completely safe materials. This durable nylon chew toy is BPA-free and made without any Phthalates. This natural chew toy is hard, durable and FDA compliant, making it a great option even for bigger, more aggressive chewers.
SHOP Nylon
15. peaksNpaws
Type Natural Dog Toy | Knotted Rope Toy
Natural Dog Toy Benefits | Eco-Friendly, Organic, USDA Certified, Recyclable, Socially Responsible, FDA-Approved
Dog Size | One Size
Favorite National Park | Glacier National Park, Bryce Canyon National Park
This all-natural rope toy from Teething Toy is the perfect toy for your dog that likes to chew or play tug of war all day. For our Teething Toy review, we love that this thick, braided toy is durable enough to withstand even heavy chewers, and that it is made only with safe and natural materials. The exterior of this rope toy is made out of braided, natural rope while the inside has a fun crinkling sound that will get dogs excited to play.
We love that this rope toy is made with eco-friendly, and FDA-approved recycled water bottle parts that will help deliver that crinkling, crackling sound that pups love. The exterior of this toy is made out of 100% organic cotton fibers braided into a rope. It is even dyed with vegetable based dyes instead of toxic chemicals so you can feel good about your pup chewing on this toy all day long.
SHOP Teething Toy
Safe and Natural Dog Toys for Your Pet
If you are looking to treat your dog to a new toy that they will love—then we have a great list of options for you. These dog toys are super durable, fun and of the highest-quality for your dog, no matter how big or small they may be.
The best thing about these toys is that they are also safe, natural and eco-friendly so you can feel just as good about this dog toy as your pet does!
Lisa Czachowski is a professional social blogger and has worked on several online publications including Citrus Sleep. Lisa is an experienced content writer and copyeditor. You will find many of her works throughout CitrusSleep.com that cover a wide array of subjects including sustainability, natural, sleep products, health, fashion and many more. She is passionate about what providing as much information as possible on products you bring in your home and what we wear.
Follow Lisa at Lisa Czachowski